Now that the H1B fiasco is over.....

I asked people on LinkedIn what they thought about an upcoming Immigration Article. My LinkedIn Question asked readers about their experience or thoughts on Employee Retention. It could have been subtitled: IMMIGRATION: A BROKEN SYSTEM - Will We (THE USA) Go Down with the Ship?

______ Here is my response to one email.

Paul M. Heller, Esq. wrote:

Hi Dimitrios,

Of course what you said was very perceptive (and we are in 100% agreement); it is very sad that this country is, and has been, headed the way of the British Empire and Rome - but I do believe we are fighting an uphill battle against our own politics (too bad only US citizens vote).

Xenophobia always thrives in bad economic times (really since 1999), i.e., scapegoats and the concept of 'devil' have been around forever, and it also arises when 'McCarthyism' raises its ugly head. I coined the term "New McCarthyism" after 9/11 - but it really hasn't been picked up yet.

But I think that it isn't just "bad economic times"; it is globalization and an economic and seismic shift that we aren't prepared for (and still don't fully understand). It is easily defended against not by closing or tightening immigration but by changing our country's immigration policy to attract those that we need "to innovate" and compete in a global market for a brighter and better future.

The "best and brightest" still want to come to this country if it affords them the opportunities and freedoms often lacking in other cultures. At this point in time we have an unbelievable 'closed door' policy (that makes absolutely no sense - except to U.S. politicians who are voted in and out of office and who feel there role in this society is to keep their job!

Fear is a powerful tool of the powerful and often used by those who govern over the governed. It is a sad time that we live in. Everyone is waiting for a true Statesman (man/woman) to arrive on the scene.

Email me directly and we will then be e-Connected; thanks.

Best,

p



On 3/30/08 8:51 AM, Dimitrios Goranitis wrote:
--------------------
Hello Paul,

I would like to reply privately to this if you dont mind.

I am a european union citizen (greek), but I spent 5 years in New York where I got my MBA and then worked for Bear Stearns and UBS. Even though I understand the problem US faces with immigration I would expect a different treatment towards low risk countries and I would call them low risk in terms of low possibility to pursue permanent stay in the US. I find two basic flaws in the current situation:

- First of all, more strict laws block human capital traffic creating a non competitive HR market. The consuquence for that would be less effective firms and finally a less effective economy.
- Second, such laws restrict the choices an expat has in terms of employment (it was clear that only a big bank and not a boutique could sponsor my visa...) and also restrict negotiating power of the employee (based on sponsoring my visa, each bank could force me to comply with its terms of employment - money, ttile)

There is an urban myth that becomes more and more intense that immigrants steal jobs from citizens, and that myth has been used as a toy in the hands of politicians in several societies. Upon this myth, politicians take measures that hurt economy and restrict its growth. Simply put, if I make money in the states, I spend it in the states and I pay taxes, feeding the economy, which expands and creates more employment opportunities.

This is my view of the situation. I hope it helps.

Best,

Dimitrios

Question Details:
--------------------
Writing an Article on U.S. Immigration Law - Employee Recruitment & Retention: The Good, Bad & Ugly.

View question - Respond to Paul M. Heller, Esq.
LinkedIn Answers
• View question

• Respond to Paul M. Heller, Esq.

What's likely to happen immigration-wise in 2008?

It is clear to this blogger, and most other experts in the field, that comprehensive immigration reform will not happen this year, certainly not until the election year 'poli-bickering' is over.

However, the idea of some reform, in piecemeal form, is not unlikely. Here are some thoughts:

1. The public still demands the focus to be on enforcement. So I don't foresee that this political need, or cover, will diminish in the near term at all. I predict we will continue to hear anti-immigration soundbites certainly until the November 2008Presidential Election.

2. If the Congress feels that the public is otherwise distracted by the inflammed and xenophobic rhetoric, then they may get on with actually making progress on immigration, including a/ creating some sort of guest worker/low skill program; and, b/ adding more visas to the H1b category (for higher skilled workers). The nurse shortage should also be addressed.

3. Regarding any sort of amnesty for those illegally here, I don't see that happening. I cross my fingers that Congress will deal with the undocumented, but don't hold your breadth.

4/ I think "our" representatives will concentrate more on a silly border fence, and even more importantly, and seriously, on creating a workable "employer verification system" mandated by earlier immigration legislation. This system, of course, would not work without a true national identity or smart card issued to everyone, including US citizens - and I wonder whether this is palatable with the American public.

5/ As things stand now, employers hiring anyone must utilize the I-9 form with serious penalities imposed for any discrimination. This provision was put in the law as being necessary to avoid employers only asking for documents from those that "don't look American". For the new system to work the employer must be able to verify everyone's document instantly. This means not only must we all be in the computer system, but that the system actually works....hmmm?

Back to ground zero - no immigration progress? Maybe.

In conclusion:

The best way to deal with this mess is to understand that we are all tracked anyway, so let's get on with it! I personally don't have a problem with a national identity or smart card myself and I think the public is changing too. In fact, the new U.S. passport is a smart card.

As stated, anyone with a U.S. passport, or who leaves and enters the country is.....tracked! Use a credit card, buy a airline ticket, groceries, or gas? Tracked. Does the U.S. government have a secret database? No one really knows. You get the picture. Privacy IS really a thing of the past.

Let's not even go there...you guessed it - the web!

Are you LinkedIn?

Dear readers,

If you haven't heard of it already, LinkedIn is a wonderful networking site for business professionals. I've found it very useful for building business relationships and would be happy to link to you.



P

_______________________________
Paul M. Heller, Esq. (Founder/Principal)

Heller Immigration Law Group, LLP
2479 E. Bayshore Rd., Suite 709
Palo Alto, CA 94303

A Silicon Valley-based law firm specializing in employment-based immigration, for corporations seeking fixed monthly retainer fee arrangements.

Toll-Free: 1/800 863-4448; Local: 1/650 424-1900; Int'l: 1/650 424-1900; Fax: 1/415 276-9099

Email: heller@hilglaw.com; www.hilglaw.com (formerly: greencard1.com)

Heller Blog: blog.hilglaw.com

YM: paulhilg